Might give it a try, just to keep most of the leaves out, and for shade next summer. If it wooks who knows, might make one out of fabric next year. Boy did I learn a lesson today. I got the sump pump hose for the batting container, and it had an adapter that fit my bulk head in the bag. I had another one in my hand but put it back. The man at the hardware store told be to cut the end off the hose and just stick the adapter in. NOT! I worked for about an hour, trying to keep that thing in that hose. Got blisters on the skin between my thumbs and index finger to prove it. Finally I said the heck with it, and tried the other end that still had the piece that I had cut off. Gave it a hard push down on the floor, and on it went. Put the clamp on and good to go. I could knock his head off for telling me that. For one thing, that sump pump hose's grooves don't spiral in like the black hose I have been using, so it couldn't get a hold, Geez!