A UV properly sized, installed and maintained is 100% effect in killing green water algae. It's like tossing a piece of paper into a fire, it's going to burn 100% of the time. But tossing a piece of paper into an unlit fireplace is not going to do anything to the paper.Also, anyone with better knowledge of uv lights relationship with algae blooms, more information would be appreciated.
So if you have green water and a UV you have a few choices. Turn it off and save electric. Keep paying for electric. Fix the UV. There are tons of threads and web pages on fixing a UV. Nutshell version:
1. Make sure the UV is rated by the manufacturer for your pond size. Not a pond size that's a teeny bit bigger.
2. Make sure the amount of water flowing thru the UV isn't more than the manufacturer rates. Few people seem to know their pump's flow rate, or the UV's, and even "flow rate" gives some people problems. So lets keep it simple. Place a ball valve on the pipe or hose between the pump and UV. If you take you hose/pipe to the hardware store they can set you up. Close the valve a bit once a week to reduce the amount of water coming out of the UV. When the pond clears you have the correct flow. Greener ponds require slower flow because the UV can't penetrate the water as far.
If you have an "all in one" UV there should be a dial on it to turn down the flow. If yours doesn't have a dial you've been screwed.
3. Replace the bulb once a year. It being lit doesn't mean it's still emitting powerful UV rays.
Algaecides, at least the ones that work, are toxic to fish. If directions are followed perfectly most Koi and Goldfish are able to survive for at least some period of time. They say "pond safe" because you wouldn't buy it otherwise. You can look up the product's material safety data sheet (MSDS) to see the real deal. That darn government people dislike so much makes them disclose the actual danger on the MSDS. Job creators sure could make a lot more money if they didn't have to disclose stuff to buyers.Anyway, after a few days my wife pointed out that we had used an algaecide for an aquarium in the house once before. it seemed to work inside so I bought some listed for ponds and used it.
Kind of like putting a "school" of 10 people into a closed garage with a car running. The flumes are toxic but it's "safe" unless the toxic levels get too high. If the levels get too high they won't all died at the same time. Sicker people go first. And just because all 10 people get out of the garage alive doesn't mean some won't die next week. Or the next time they get a cold and turns into pneumonia because their immune system was trashed in the garage.