Well, I haven't posted for a while. That doesn't mean that I've been idle!!
When I built the pond walls, I used the earth as a form for the concrete ring at the bottom of the wall, on which the concrete block sits. Not a great idea as it turns out, since that doesn't give a smooth surface to lay the liner on. So, I got a diamond cutting wheel and smoothed that part of the wall out to some degree, and also smoothed out the joint of some of the concrete blocks where I hadn't got a real nice joint.
I decided that the liner would still need some more "cushioning" to prevent damage, and found this pink 1/4" foamboard insulation at Home Depot. It comes fan-fold, and one bundle of it did my pond and bog walls with just a small amount remaining when I was finished! (Usually, it seems that I have 90% of the last bundle of material left when I've finished a project, but this worked out perfectly.)
Then the job was to attach this foamboard to the concrete block wall. Following the advice of my usual building-supply people, I used PL300 foamboard adhesive. Sounds like the right thing, doesn't it? I applied a good ribbon of the adhesive along the face of the block, near the top, got the foamboard in place, and clamped it with supporting pieces of wood to get good contact between foam and concrete. I just glued it along the top, as water pressure will keep it in place otherwise, and because there's no way to clamp it for gluing at lower places along the wall.
In the morning I took off the clamps, and in the afternoon and evening we had rain. In the morning, there is all the fanfold foamboard standing happily around, like office workers at the water cooler, hardly attached to the wall at all. It turns out that PL300 is
water soluble!
Not exactly what I was hoping for!
After a couple of days of drying out, I re-did all the gluing, re-using the same foamboard, and standard construction adhesive, and it has held just fine through several rainstorms.