So, how do these vacuums work? Are they basically a shop vac with added features? If so, what is the difference? Do you end up sucking a lot of pond water out? Basically a partial water change?
The oasis pond vac actions just like a wet dry vac except it has two chambers in the body with two float switches. So when the one side fills up it toggles to the other side. At that point the first side is draining as the second side fills. Back and forth it goes. You could use a wet dry vac but would have to stop and drain it constantly.
They do pull plenty of water out with the junk but since you are for the most part targeting what you want out .. they seem efficient. A partial water change is good anyway.
I end up putting my fishing net at the end of the waste hose to catch the leaves and big stuff to easily toss into the garden. The rest of the muck can get hosed into the lawn.