I always liked your pond Tmann and what you did with your backyard, and I'm sure the people who bought your place liked it too.
There are a lot of factors that come into play when selling a home and it's true that having a pond can turn off some people, but so can a swimming pool, having a big lawn to mow (a personal turn off for me), having stairs in the house (a turn off for elderly or infirm people), having a particularly small yard or kitchen, etc,,, but generally the top of the list of all is a high price tag. Slash the selling price of the house and a lot of people are willing to overlook any perceived negatives. In general if you are unwilling, or unable, to drastically lower the selling price of your home for a quick sell then you'll have to wait for the right buyers and 8 months doesn't sound too unreasonable.
Recently we have been entertaining the idea of selling our place and moving to another province, and so I have a TO Do list of unfinished project I plan to start checking off a list, but filling in the pond is not on that list. Top of the list is turning our sauna room into a bathroom. We only have one bathroom in the house right now and although the sauna room is nice it's not as much of a selling feature as having two bathrooms is. Besides, I'm planning to add a steam generator to the shower stall in this new bathroom to turn it into a steam shower.
I hated leaving the pond we built in our last place, and I was determined to make any new pond better (and slightly bigger), if and when we got around to building it, which we did, although it took a few years before we were able to get around to it. One thing I did was to make the new pond easier to maintain, so hopefully any potential buyers will recognize that, although I may have to instill that bit of information into my realtor so they can pass it along.
Of course we also did many other extensive renovations to this place to the tune of $40,000+ and I know I'll likely never get monetarily compensated for all the personal sweat and toil we put into it, but as long as we can pull out a little more $$$ then we put into it I'll be happy, I'll just have to absorb the bulk of the labor costs I guess.
I plan to make our pond and courtyard our prime selling feature to hopefully attract the right kind of buyers right from the start, and to any buyers who think the pond is a negative......
Finally got use that emoticon.