I'm going to try to keep all pumps running this year again. Last year, Skippy filter/waterfall kept freezing and shutting down. Pump is 4200 gph on a milk crate about 14" from bottom of the pond, but water line ran about 15' outside the water on top of the ground. This year, I moved that waterline so only 8' of it is buried about 8" below the dirt, and has insulation sleeve over it, rest is in the water. Hoping that will help. Skimmer line runs in the water to the bog, that never stopped last year. In the goldfish pond, skimmer feeds the stream, which ran all winter, and the big 4200 gph pump on milk crate there fed the large bog, which also ran all year. So, we shall see how the waterfall Skippy does this year. I also have a water bubbler in the goldfish pond to keep ice open in front of the skimmer, and an air bubbler in the koi pond in front of that skimmer. Those are on milk crates as well, so not circulating water from the bottom of the ponds. Only turn them on when ice threatens. Have heater to open holes when/if necessary. Good luck this winter, everyone! I expect a much harsher winter than the last 2 VERY mild ones.