It seems EPDM under polyurea helps for extra thick seal. My son who applies SLC works for Flexible Lining Systems. Between pond owner neighbors and my son, EPDM works but anything made of rubber breaks down pretty quick. My original pond's EPDM from Firestone got brittle, cracked, leaked. That was before the boy became a spray lining coatings applicator. I assume if EPDM can be sprayed or rolled it may be better than those 45-60 mil sheets. But so far polyurea was the only coating that did not decompose over time. I visited pondpro2000.com-got msds(chemical specs)- got this scary stuff: "HEALTH HAZARDS (ACUTE AND CHRONIC), Overexposure can lead to Central Nervous System Depression producing effects such as headache, dizziness, nausea and loss of consciousness.CARCINOGENICITY: NTP? NO IARC MONOGRAPHS? NO OSHA REGULATED? YES Contains cobalt, which is known to the State of California to cause cancer or birth defects and is subject to the requirements of California Proposition 65. MEDICAL CONDITIONS GENERALLY AGGRAVATED BY EXPOSURE, Conditions aggravated by exposure may include skin and respiratory disorders." Yikes! EPDM once dry in the sheets isn't dangerous but as a spray that may be superior. I know that "pure" polyurea is also carcinogenic (needs respirator, protective clothes) to spray. This "polyurea hybrid" I still use is a spray lining and coating that's safe, however. Don't need to apply the spray-lining over Firestone or other EPDM sheets either. I think SLC has a roll on polyurea hybrid now too. Linda Robert appears like an advertisement but the idea of spray-lining or roll-lining EPDM may help if it wasn't hazardous.