I believe they are Northern Leopard Frogs, but those two picks show very clearly what I saw in my research. The two frogs are similar for sure, but what I have are defiitely not Pickerels. I think the decider is if Pickerel frogs can poison each other, I probably wouldn't have a dozen of them in my goldfish pond. These little guys are always touching while hiding in my frog condo.
And the toads are just standard American Toads. Nothing fancy, just really loud.
I'll research it today, but I'm positive that Indiana doesn't allow the removal of any frogs from their natural environment. So me taking a frog from my backyard and putting it anywhere else, the river, a lake, a cardboard box, is forbidden.
Shipping does seem tough, I feel like a sealed bag with a little water would kill it, but a loosely packed box with something moist and air holes would kill it as well.