I've bought a lot of pumps over the years (maybe 100?) and I've never seen any pattern other than maybe the stuff sold at big box stores. I don't like filter/pump combos or any pump that has a fountain because it's a sign of low quality imo.
First time I do is remove the foam pre-filter if there is one and throw it out. I often also toss out the plastic cage around the intake for the reason you cited. I'm talking mag drive type pumps. I normally place the pump behind the skimmer so that acts as the pre-filter. Otherwise some mid to high point so it's not pulling in stuff from the bottom or surface where most clogging stuff is.
I've made many filters in my day, like you wouldn't believe many. The best filter for removing waste I found was no filter. Unless of course you get into high end filters which I assume are out of the question here. The best, cheapest, easiest way is a vacuum. My page on vacuum options. Once you can on top of the vacuuming lots of other things will get easier too like pumps not clogging.
You couldn't pay me to mess around with DIY mechanical filters any more. Bio, sieve sure.
First time I do is remove the foam pre-filter if there is one and throw it out. I often also toss out the plastic cage around the intake for the reason you cited. I'm talking mag drive type pumps. I normally place the pump behind the skimmer so that acts as the pre-filter. Otherwise some mid to high point so it's not pulling in stuff from the bottom or surface where most clogging stuff is.
I've made many filters in my day, like you wouldn't believe many. The best filter for removing waste I found was no filter. Unless of course you get into high end filters which I assume are out of the question here. The best, cheapest, easiest way is a vacuum. My page on vacuum options. Once you can on top of the vacuuming lots of other things will get easier too like pumps not clogging.
You couldn't pay me to mess around with DIY mechanical filters any more. Bio, sieve sure.