Bog filter question

Joined
Aug 22, 2022
Messages
58
Reaction score
86
Country
United States
Hi all,

Looking to add a bog filter to my pond. Currently I’m filtering everything through and intake an a waterfall. I’m hoping to put a pump(purchased a Aquascape AquaForce 5200 Pump) in my pond and pump water out of the pond up to the bog. The bog will filter and water will flow down a waterfall back into the pond.

The only worry is string algae and other things going through my pump and causing issues. Is there anything besides a mesh bag around the pump you would do to help prevent this from happening? Current pond pics below.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1046.jpeg
    IMG_1046.jpeg
    388.8 KB · Views: 50
  • IMG_0785.jpeg
    IMG_0785.jpeg
    406.9 KB · Views: 51
  • IMG_0760.jpeg
    IMG_0760.jpeg
    390.8 KB · Views: 51

j.w

I Love my Goldies
Joined
Feb 1, 2010
Messages
33,826
Reaction score
20,817
Location
Arlington, Washington
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
USDA 8a
Country
United States
Hi all,

Looking to add a bog filter to my pond. Currently I’m filtering everything through and intake an a waterfall. I’m hoping to put a pump(purchased a Aquascape AquaForce 5200 Pump) in my pond and pump water out of the pond up to the bog. The bog will filter and water will flow down a waterfall back into the pond.

The only worry is string algae and other things going through my pump and causing issues. Is there anything besides a mesh bag around the pump you would do to help prevent this from happening? Current pond pics below.
Wow your pond is great and looks like it has no liner. I know it does as I saw your building of it. Swim w/the fish! How fun for everyone!
 
Joined
Jul 9, 2024
Messages
1
Reaction score
2
Country
United States
I have been working on my pond for the past 2 1/2 years. short history:
-buy a house with an overgrown pond bordering woodland. Have overgrowth removed year one. Clear path around and start to rake out muck end of year one.
-read, watch videos (understatement) on bog filters; decide to try it out. Continue raking leaves, removing trees and widening what will eventually be the "beach". Problem: This was originally dug as a retention pond at just above lowest level of the property spring overflow goes into a swamp below. EVERYTHING filters down into the pond.
- spend year two redirecting water left and right of the pond. Works to a degree; a work in progress.
- spring of year three, buy two used food grade 50 gallon drums and a 1/4hp sump pump plus 10 bags of pea gravel from Home Depot. The pump was in a milk crate placed on paving stones. I still had to clean out the barrel and filter every two weeks or so. The barrel was filled about 5/8 full of pea gravel, fed from the bottom. The lower barrel had about three inches of pea gravel. The system worked in that the water that came out was clearer than the water that went in. BUT, I had underestimated the amount of muck on the bottom of the pond.
-Winter of year three: ditch the barrels and use the pump to lower the water, about a foot at a time, so that I could dig out muck. All this time, I have been drawing, planning (my husband calls it "scheming") how my bog filter would work, once I removed the tree stumps I uncovered - still a work in progress, though most are gone.
Ok, so not so short a history, year 4 begins with removing muck by the bucket full, using the Kubota where I could, but mostly digging and filling the bucket shovel full by shovel full. Then the rains came. I did remove the largest stump (the one with the turkeys on it) and have actually begun my filter system. I realized that I needed to keep more leaves from getting in the pond, so phase one was/is a skimmer filter. I have the pad poured and some of the wall up. I also purchased an inground pool skimmer and have researched pumps. For now, I will probably buy a 3/4 hp pump and sand filter, since I will only be filtering the surface water, used, if possible.
I got some advice from a nephew who is a civil engineer. He suggested that I line the pond. I am not certain that I can afford to line the entire pond, but I have covered several areas when the rain washes dried muck back into the pond. I have used about 6 tons of marine base so far, at about $30 a ton (plus delivery) and estimate that I will need 20 tons more. Not this year!
I tried to load my original sketch, but I keep getting an error message that the file is too large. The biggest part of this project is the bog itself. In its current iteration, it will be about 450 sq feet at about 2 ft high, with 12 inches of filter material. I was originally going with pea gravel, but recent reading has me unsure. I do not have to worry about rough edges, since the bog is cement, so I just need to drill down on the pros and cons of different size, shape, and material.

Has anyone ever attempted to convert a retention pond into a swimming hole? My research says that I need a bog about 20% of the size of my pond. I do not have room for a bog that big! I do have springs in the pond.
The pond is about 60ft by 50 ft at full/overflow height. At that point, it is about 5-6 feet deep in the center. Where I have dug, I am removing muck up to a foot deep. There is sand below, but I don't know at what depth. I will be renting an excavator for the final deep dig, and hope that after bringing in 3 - 4 inches of marine limestone base, that depth at the center will be at least 6 feet. Am I a fool for trying?2.apr15 2023.jpgDNAD1661.JPGIMG_2094.jpg13.may21 2024.jpgJune4 2024.jpg-1845671671306801210.jpg6.oct7 2023.jpg
 

j.w

I Love my Goldies
Joined
Feb 1, 2010
Messages
33,826
Reaction score
20,817
Location
Arlington, Washington
Showcase(s):
1
Hardiness Zone
USDA 8a
Country
United States
welcome-1-1-1.gif
@KathyZ
Wow that's one big huge pond!
Never a fool for trying and hope you succeed.
Will you be swimming w/fish or will it be fish free?
 
Joined
May 24, 2019
Messages
1,593
Reaction score
2,645
Location
Tennessee
Hardiness Zone
7a
Country
United States
I have been working on my pond for the past 2 1/2 years. short history:
-buy a house with an overgrown pond bordering woodland. Have overgrowth removed year one. Clear path around and start to rake out muck end of year one.
-read, watch videos (understatement) on bog filters; decide to try it out. Continue raking leaves, removing trees and widening what will eventually be the "beach". Problem: This was originally dug as a retention pond at just above lowest level of the property spring overflow goes into a swamp below. EVERYTHING filters down into the pond.
- spend year two redirecting water left and right of the pond. Works to a degree; a work in progress.
- spring of year three, buy two used food grade 50 gallon drums and a 1/4hp sump pump plus 10 bags of pea gravel from Home Depot. The pump was in a milk crate placed on paving stones. I still had to clean out the barrel and filter every two weeks or so. The barrel was filled about 5/8 full of pea gravel, fed from the bottom. The lower barrel had about three inches of pea gravel. The system worked in that the water that came out was clearer than the water that went in. BUT, I had underestimated the amount of muck on the bottom of the pond.
-Winter of year three: ditch the barrels and use the pump to lower the water, about a foot at a time, so that I could dig out muck. All this time, I have been drawing, planning (my husband calls it "scheming") how my bog filter would work, once I removed the tree stumps I uncovered - still a work in progress, though most are gone.
Ok, so not so short a history, year 4 begins with removing muck by the bucket full, using the Kubota where I could, but mostly digging and filling the bucket shovel full by shovel full. Then the rains came. I did remove the largest stump (the one with the turkeys on it) and have actually begun my filter system. I realized that I needed to keep more leaves from getting in the pond, so phase one was/is a skimmer filter. I have the pad poured and some of the wall up. I also purchased an inground pool skimmer and have researched pumps. For now, I will probably buy a 3/4 hp pump and sand filter, since I will only be filtering the surface water, used, if possible.
I got some advice from a nephew who is a civil engineer. He suggested that I line the pond. I am not certain that I can afford to line the entire pond, but I have covered several areas when the rain washes dried muck back into the pond. I have used about 6 tons of marine base so far, at about $30 a ton (plus delivery) and estimate that I will need 20 tons more. Not this year!
I tried to load my original sketch, but I keep getting an error message that the file is too large. The biggest part of this project is the bog itself. In its current iteration, it will be about 450 sq feet at about 2 ft high, with 12 inches of filter material. I was originally going with pea gravel, but recent reading has me unsure. I do not have to worry about rough edges, since the bog is cement, so I just need to drill down on the pros and cons of different size, shape, and material.

Has anyone ever attempted to convert a retention pond into a swimming hole? My research says that I need a bog about 20% of the size of my pond. I do not have room for a bog that big! I do have springs in the pond.
The pond is about 60ft by 50 ft at full/overflow height. At that point, it is about 5-6 feet deep in the center. Where I have dug, I am removing muck up to a foot deep. There is sand below, but I don't know at what depth. I will be renting an excavator for the final deep dig, and hope that after bringing in 3 - 4 inches of marine limestone base, that depth at the center will be at least 6 feet. Am I a fool for trying?View attachment 164371View attachment 164373View attachment 164374View attachment 164376View attachment 164377View attachment 164378View attachment 164379
Wow what a project! Soooo much work. There are some very skilled folks here with lots of construction experience that will likely jump in to give you their 2cents. All I can say is congrats on all your hard work!
 
Joined
Aug 22, 2022
Messages
58
Reaction score
86
Country
United States
I have been working on my pond for the past 2 1/2 years. short history:
-buy a house with an overgrown pond bordering woodland. Have overgrowth removed year one. Clear path around and start to rake out muck end of year one.
-read, watch videos (understatement) on bog filters; decide to try it out. Continue raking leaves, removing trees and widening what will eventually be the "beach". Problem: This was originally dug as a retention pond at just above lowest level of the property spring overflow goes into a swamp below. EVERYTHING filters down into the pond.
- spend year two redirecting water left and right of the pond. Works to a degree; a work in progress.
- spring of year three, buy two used food grade 50 gallon drums and a 1/4hp sump pump plus 10 bags of pea gravel from Home Depot. The pump was in a milk crate placed on paving stones. I still had to clean out the barrel and filter every two weeks or so. The barrel was filled about 5/8 full of pea gravel, fed from the bottom. The lower barrel had about three inches of pea gravel. The system worked in that the water that came out was clearer than the water that went in. BUT, I had underestimated the amount of muck on the bottom of the pond.
-Winter of year three: ditch the barrels and use the pump to lower the water, about a foot at a time, so that I could dig out muck. All this time, I have been drawing, planning (my husband calls it "scheming") how my bog filter would work, once I removed the tree stumps I uncovered - still a work in progress, though most are gone.
Ok, so not so short a history, year 4 begins with removing muck by the bucket full, using the Kubota where I could, but mostly digging and filling the bucket shovel full by shovel full. Then the rains came. I did remove the largest stump (the one with the turkeys on it) and have actually begun my filter system. I realized that I needed to keep more leaves from getting in the pond, so phase one was/is a skimmer filter. I have the pad poured and some of the wall up. I also purchased an inground pool skimmer and have researched pumps. For now, I will probably buy a 3/4 hp pump and sand filter, since I will only be filtering the surface water, used, if possible.
I got some advice from a nephew who is a civil engineer. He suggested that I line the pond. I am not certain that I can afford to line the entire pond, but I have covered several areas when the rain washes dried muck back into the pond. I have used about 6 tons of marine base so far, at about $30 a ton (plus delivery) and estimate that I will need 20 tons more. Not this year!
I tried to load my original sketch, but I keep getting an error message that the file is too large. The biggest part of this project is the bog itself. In its current iteration, it will be about 450 sq feet at about 2 ft high, with 12 inches of filter material. I was originally going with pea gravel, but recent reading has me unsure. I do not have to worry about rough edges, since the bog is cement, so I just need to drill down on the pros and cons of different size, shape, and material.

Has anyone ever attempted to convert a retention pond into a swimming hole? My research says that I need a bog about 20% of the size of my pond. I do not have room for a bog that big! I do have springs in the pond.
The pond is about 60ft by 50 ft at full/overflow height. At that point, it is about 5-6 feet deep in the center. Where I have dug, I am removing muck up to a foot deep. There is sand below, but I don't know at what depth. I will be renting an excavator for the final deep dig, and hope that after bringing in 3 - 4 inches of marine limestone base, that depth at the center will be at least 6 feet. Am I a fool for trying?View attachment 164371View attachment 164373View attachment 164374View attachment 164376View attachment 164377View attachment 164378View attachment 164379
That definitely is a massive project. All the research I did said don’t target low areas to create a pond :). I built my pond in a low area that was covered with trees, muck and water in the spring. It always dried up by mid summer. I dug it out, lined it covered the liner in sand and rock, definitely needed to be weighted down in case of a heavy rain.

Needless to say it has worked out so far I’m in the process of adding a bog. I also added a French drain to help divert some water. You probably can do this but it will be more difficult.
 

Ask a Question

Want to reply to this thread or ask your own question?

You'll need to choose a username for the site, which only take a couple of moments. After that, you can post your question and our members will help you out.

Ask a Question

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
31,508
Messages
517,998
Members
13,714
Latest member
Cagio

Latest Threads

Top