Hey Meyer, I never used the products you mentioned but had a couple of questions. What temperatures should they be applied? If applied to early before the filters are up in running fully, will is cause issues due to killing off the natural filtration of the algae?
In answer to your first question, Phosphorus binders work at any temperature. The answer to your second question is not quite so simple. First of all, we are talking controlling filamentous algae not the other attached and planktonic specie which will remain. The re-activation rate of bioconversion (Filters) is determined by 1) Temperature and 2) availability of Ammonia. At low temperatures, the respiration rate of fish is also low. As a result, very little Ammonia is released into the water. As temperatures rise, the metabolic and respiration rate increase releasing more Ammonia into the water. In addition, as temperatures increase more of this Ammonia is non-ionized or free ammonia which is what the Ammonia Oxidizing Bacteria (AOB) require to function and grow. So the re-activation rate of bioconversion is doubly linked to temperature; directly and indirectly.
If there is an algae growth (non-filamentous), then, because most algae is Nitrate dependent, there must be Nitrate present in the water column. For this to occur, some bio-conversion must be taking place or the pond has carried an elevated Nitrate level for some time.
Elimination of filamentous algae will have very minimal effect on water quality, but because of its mechanical filtering abilities, water clarity may be effective.
If filamentous algae is allowed to grow over an extended period of time, it can, indirectly, be minimally beneficial to water quality. Nitrate dependent algae will actually colonize the surface area of the filamentous algae (epiphytic algae) (see photo).